Welcome to the
first issue of the Hawai‘i Journal of Public Health. Why a new
public health journal for Hawai‘i? First, this Journal offers
public health professionals, academics, students, and even members of
the public from Hawai‘i and the Pacific a venue for publishing their
Hawai‘i and Pacific-based research in a publication which is targeted at
Hawai‘i and the Pacific. This aim is particularly true for the
three thousand staff members of the Hawai‘i State Department of
Health, where Director Chiyome Leina‘ala Fukino sees the Journal as an
essential tool for workforce improvement.
What is the
Journal? As the name states, we are a Journal of public health.
Our focus is on all disciplines of public health, from chronic disease
to environmental, maternal and child health to infection control.
We aim to improve the quality of public health practiced everywhere in
Hawai‘i and the Pacific by providing a forum for students, practitioners
and the public to share their research and learn about the research and
best practices of others. We are not a journal of clinical
medicine.
While we
welcome submissions from any location, our focus is on Hawai‘i and the
Pacific. Specifically, we hope that the research, policies and
commentary published in the Journal will be a resource for public health
practitioners, students and the public in Hawai‘i and the Pacific.
At the same time, public health is global, and we recognize the
substantial links of Hawai‘i and the Pacific to locations such as the
continental United States. Thus, we particularly encourage
submissions from authors concerning populations from Hawai‘i and the
Pacific who have settled in other areas.
Although our
Journal will remain a high-quality, peer-reviewed publication, we also
recognize the need to encourage first-time authors to publish.
Thus, we will work with authors to make their work publishable, if at
all possible. While maintaining high standards, we believe that we
should facilitate, rather than be a barrier to, publication. To
this aim, we offer a wide variety of formats, from the traditional
original research articles to brief reports, student submissions, and a
discussion section where issues of public health can be debated.
We are
particularly grateful to all the section editors and peer reviewers,
without whose help this Journal is not possible.
Mahalo for
your interest in the first issue of the Hawai‘i Journal of Public
Health, and we look forward to your participation in this new endeavor.
Me ka
ha‘aha‘a,
Kawika Liu
and Andrew Grandinetti
Co-editors,
Hawai‘i Journal of Public Health.
A Few Thoughts on
Public Health and Our Healthcare Crisis
Chiyome Leinaala Fukino, MD
1Hawaii
State Department of Health
Public Health is something of a mystery to most people. In the
minds of many, the services and purposes of public health and clinical
medicine are essentially the same. The confusion is understandable
because in many states, public health departments have become the
“provider of last resort”, assuring access to direct healthcare services
for vulnerable populations such as the mentally ill, homeless and
uninsured.
By definition, Public Health protects and improves the health of
communities through education, promotion of healthy lifestyles, and
research to prevent disease and injury. By contrast, Clinical
Medicine maintains or restores the health of individuals through
study, diagnosis and treatment of individual patients.
Regulatory functions of Public Health in Hawaii assure that our
communities have clean air, clean water, safe food, safe drinking water,
proper sewage treatment and appropriate solid and hazardous waste
disposal. We license many types of healthcare facilities and
certify practioners in various public health related professions.
We work with many community partners to solve current health and safety
problems and practice with them in preparation for future natural or man
made disasters and disease outbreaks. These are just a few of the
activities of the Hawaii State Department of Health.
It is no secret that healthcare in the United States is in crisis,
providing some of the best and some of the worst healthcare the world
has to offer! Many are not happy with the ways things are right
now, but clearly, this is the healthcare industry that we built.
Rushing to enact healthcare reforms based on perceived benefits of
nationalized health care systems in other countries without unbiased
evaluations of their advantages and disadvantages, as well as
appropriate consideration of our own unique cultural, legal and
political differences will only serve to aggravate an already bad
situation.
An effective partnership of the two great health houses—Public Health
and Clinical Medicine, must be forged if we are to solve our nation’s
“healthcare crisis”.
One of the most significant things that Public Health does is to focus
on prevention efforts now in order to reduce the need for expensive
tertiary healthcare services later. Good nutrition, regular
physical activity and abstinence from tobacco and other illicit drugs
are health habits that greatly improve the quality and duration of our
lives, no matter what our gene pool may be. These good health
habits are well understood by the health savvy, but for many adults,
consistent educational outreach is needed to improve health knowledge
and counteract decades of physical neglect. Early education of our
children in environments supportive of these good health habits is
essential!
Public Health in Hawaii must take an active role in shaping our natural
environment and helping individuals to shape their personal environments
to enable consistent application of good health habits which decreases
future demand for Clinical Medicine services.
Health Disparities
in Hawai‘i:
Part 1 David MKI Liu1, R Kekuni Blaisdell[1],
Nia Aitaoto2 ,1Office
of Health Equity, Hawai‘i State
Department of Health, Office of Public Health Studies, John A Burns
School of Medicine, University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa 2Department
of Native Hawaiian Health, John A Burns School of Medicine, University
of Hawai‘i at Mānoa 3Papa
Ola Lōkahi
Abstract
Objective:
Although the United Health Foundation ranked Hawai‘i as the third
healthiest state in the United States in 2007, this status is not shared
equally among the peoples of Hawai‘i. Studies have identified
disparities in breast cancer screening, body mass index (BMI), the use
of mental health services by women with depressive symptoms, adherence
to antihypertensive medications, breast cancer management and breast
cancer survival, in addition to many other health areas. Lacking,
however, is a comprehensive examination of health disparities across the
most populous ethnic groups in Hawai‘i – Native Hawaiians, Caucasians,
Japanese, Chinese, and other Pacific Islanders. This series presents
these data, beginning with an introduction and continuing to present
data on disparities on obesity, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and
other chronic illnesses.More
[1]
Department of Native Hawaiian Health, University of Hawai‘i John
A Burns School of Medicine, Honolulu, Hawai‘i.
Academic Public
Health at the University of Hawaii at Manoa
Jay Maddock
Department of Public Health Studies, John A Burns School of Medicine,
University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa.
It gives me great
pleasure to see this inaugural issue of the Hawaii Journal of Public
Health. The journal provides another strong link between the
public health academic and practice communities in Hawaii. Over
the past few years, several linkages have been made between the Office
of Public Health Studies and the Hawaii Department of Health to better
address public health issues. This includes the Science Officer’s
Program, Hawaii Health Data Warehouse, the Healthy Hawaii Initiative and
several student practical experiences. We look forward to
additional academic-practice linkages in the future.
More
Modelling accessibility to primary
health care using a spatial accessibility index and a need index
Nasser
Bagheri1, George L. Benwell1, Alec Holt1
1Department of Information Science, University of Otago, New Zealand
Abstract
Objectives: This research developed an integrated approach for
modelling accessibility to primary health care (PHC) services using a
spatial accessibility index and a need index.
Methods: New Zealand and World Health Organisation (WHO)
rules were used to determine optimum levels of minimum travel time and
modelling high need groups. A two-step Floating Catchment Area
(FCA) method was used to calculate spatial accessibility index based on
travel time. NZDep2001 score was also used to model high health
need people and generating the need index. Then, spatial and need
indices combined into one framework by using math tool in ArcInfo
version 9.2.
Results: The
results of this study have shown that some parts of north and central
Otago (with a population of 4048 that comprises about 5.4 percent of the
total rural Otago population) do not meet the WHO rules and New Zealand
guidelines for access to primary health care (during business hours).
The paper showed that people living in some areas of central rural Otago
suffers from long travel time and high need to PHC facilities.
Conclusion: The
paper illustrated the “accessibility index” as a tool to model the level
of spatial accessibility of people to primary health care. A “need
index”, as a surrogate tool for illustrating accessibility to primary
health is also modelled. Then it is indicated that a better
approach is to combine the spatial accessibility and need indices
together.
More
Promoting Science-Based Approaches to
Teen Pregnancy Prevention
Judith F. Clark1
1Hawai`i
Youth Services Network
Abstract
Background.
Hawai`i ranks 12th in the nation for teen pregnancy
prevalence. Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islanders demonstrate a
disproportionate share of teen pregnancies, accounting for more than 60%
of the total teen births. Local organizations lacked the organizational
capacity and funding to conduct needs assessments, select appropriate
interventions, or evaluate results of teen pregnancy prevention
programs. Youth workers had little knowledge of science-based
programs and often believe that programs developed elsewhere will not
work in Hawai`i.
Purpose.
To address these issues, the Hawai`i Youth Services Network (HYSN) has
worked with Hawai`i-based organizations since 2005 to build
organizational capacity to select, implement and evaluate science-based
approaches to teen pregnancy prevention.
Approaches.
HYSN helps organizations assess community needs, develop goals and
objectives, assess programs for community fit, make culturally
appropriate adaptations to curricula, and implement, evaluate, and
sustain their efforts. HYSN also provides intensive training and
customized technical assistance, develops peer support, and identifies
and removes barriers for organizations that want to offer more effective
programs.
Findings.
At the beginning of the project, few, if any, Hawai`i organizations were
using science-based programs, and none were conducting evaluation.
After two years, at least eight organizations have selected and
implemented science-based curricula aimed at preventing teen pregnancy,
and we are evaluating the effectiveness with Hawaiian, Pacific Islands,
and Asian youth.
Discussion.
This project demonstrates the critical importance of building peer
support and offering ongoing training and technical assistance to build
capacity to implement effective programs for the prevention of teen
pregnancy.
More
Examination of bed bug (Cimex
lectularius Linnaeus) infestations on the island of Oahu, Hawaii
Victoria J. Fickle1,
Pingjun Yang1, Gregory K. Olmsted1
1Hawaii State Department of Health, Vector Control Branch
Abstract: Bed bug (Cimex lectularius Linnaeus) infestations have been
increasing over the past several years in the continental United States.
This study identified a similar rise in bed bug infestations on the
island of Oahu, Hawai’i and followed up to characterize the local
situation. The amount of calls and complaints regarding bed bugs
to the Hawai’i State Department of Health, Oahu Vector Control Branch
(DOHVCB) and Pest Control Companies (PCCs) increased in 2007 as compared
to 2006. Eighteen pest management professionals (PMPs) were
interviewed by phone in follow up. The number of sites treated for a
company ranged from 2 to 650 in 2007, with a mean of 95.31 sites
treated. Residential facilities were most commonly serviced by PMPs,
shelters much less often. Eighteen employees from 16 shelters were
then also interviewed using a different, in-person survey form.
Eleven of these shelters had experienced a bed bug infestation, two of
which were still affected at the time of the interview. Sixty-four
percent of shelters’ infestations were limited to one incident, 87.50%
of these were able to quickly eliminate infestations. To be able
to contain an infestation in shelters such as these, training staff on
prevention measures is critical. With the overall rise in
infestations, updated public information is essential.
More
Lack of Prenatal Care–A Re-Emerging
Health Problem on Guam
Robert L. Haddock,1Margaret
Murphy-Bell,2
Cynthia L. Naval,3Carolyn
Garrido,4 1Office
of Epidemiology and Research,
2Maternal
and Child Health Program, 3Office
of Planning and Evaluation 4Office
of Vital Statistics
Abstract
Objective:
A study was conducted to determine the ethnic profile of new mothers
on Guam, their use of prenatal care services, causes for the failure
of some women to receive any prenatal care, and suggestions to
improve participation in this important health care measure.
Methods:
Data from birth certificates for the period 1970-2004 were reviewed
to determine the ethnicity of mothers and their prenatal care.
In addition, a survey of mothers who delivered without any prenatal
care was conducted to learn their reasons for not receiving prenatal
care, where they would prefer to receive such care in the future,
and their suggestions for encouraging participation in prenatal care
programs.
Results:
The
percent of Micronesian mothers who received no prenatal care during
their pregnancies increased by more than 4 times (461%) over the
study period. Lack of medical
insurance (24.3% of respondents) and lack of transportation (22.6%
of respondents) were the leading reasons given for not receiving
prenatal care during their pregnancies. Nearly half (48.2%) of
respondents indicated they would prefer to receive prenatal care at
public health clinics, the number favoring North, Central, or
Southern clinics roughly reflecting population numbers of the areas
served by those clinics.
Conclusions: Targeted measures should be taken to assure that basic prenatal care is
accessible to mothers who do not have health insurance and have
limited transportation resources.
More
Examining
the predictive value of the theory of
planned behavior and stages of change on fruit and vegetable intake
Daniela S Kittinger1, Sarabibi T Mayet1, Sonya
Niess1, Jamie Kopera1, Stefan Keller1,
Jay Maddock1.
(1) Department
of Public Health Studies, John A Burns School of Medicine,
University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa.
Abstract
Objective: Most research
examining the Theory of Planned Behavior(TPB) and the
Transtheoretical model’s stages of change(SOC) in predicting fruit
and vegetable(FV) intake has been cross-sectional in nature. The aim
of this study was to investigate the strength of these variables in
predicting FV consumption and SOC after one year.
Methods:
A random-digit dial phone panel survey was administered in spring of
2006(T1) and followed up in fall of 2007(T2). Participants were
English-speaking adults residing in the state of Hawaiʻi. Data included the 722 participants who were not meeting
the 5-a-day recommendation at baseline. TPB variables(attitudes,
perceived behavioral control(PBC), and social norms) were assessed,
with stage of change(SOC), substituted for intention. Self efficacy,
barriers, and dietary behavior were also measured. Various analyses
were run investigating the predictive value of these variables on
future FV intake.
Results: Without
accounting for baseline FV intake, self efficacy and PBC
significantly predicted whether or not the 5-a-day recommendation
was reached, and self efficacy and barriers significantly predicted
the number of servings consumed at follow up. However, when previous
FV intake was accounted for, this variable explained most of the
variance in behavior, rendering all other variables non-significant
predictors. Some evidence was found supporting the temporal notion
inherent in the SOC construct, namely that more people progressed
forward through the stages than regressed backward. However, the
majority of people in both the pre-contemplation and preparation
stages tended to remain in that stage at T2.
Conclusion:
After controlling for potential confounding variables, the TPB
constructs and stages of change were not significant predictors of
future FV intake. Some support was seen for SOC progression.
More
Evidence-based Youth Drug
Prevention:
A Critique with Implications for Practice-Based Contextually Relevant
Prevention in Hawai‘i
Objective:
Publicly funded health
and human services increasingly require the use of nationally-endorsed
programs, therefore we review these youth drug prevention programs
through the lens of Hawaii based practitioners. This review indicated a
chasm in contextually relevant programs and practices created for or by
Native Hawaiian, Asian-American, and other Pacific Peoples. This problem
is outlined and then we describe a rationale for using participatory
research to develop practice-based evidence in drug prevention that is
contextually relevant to youth, their families and communities, and
youth-serving organizations in Hawai‘i. Practice-based evidence refers
to locally designed, implemented, and evaluated practice; thus providing
evidence about what is working (and how) for a specific context.
Contextual relevance refers both to ethnocultural significance, and
place based neighborhood and community dynamics.
More
Community-Acquired Methicillin-Resistant
Staphylococcus aureus.
Investigation on a United States Navy Ship
Joseph A Sliman1,
Bardwell J Eberly3, Dana Ann Tamashiro2, ,
Precilia S Calimlim2,
A. Christian Whelen 2,3
1Navy
Environmental and Preventive Medicine Unit Six, Pearl Harbor, Hawai‘i.
2State
Laboratories Division, Hawaii State Department of Health, Pearl City,
Hawai‘i.
3Microbiology
Services, Department of Pathology, Tripler Army Medical Center,
Honolulu, Hawai‘i.
Abstract
Objective: Investigate colonization and risk factors
associated with an outbreak of community-associated
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus (CA-MRSA) skin and soft tissue infections
(SSTI) on a United States Navy surface ship.
Methods: Descriptive survey of outbreak population
characteristics and culture–based surveillance of the ship population
for colonization with Staphylococcus aureus.
Results: Eighty-five percent (266/313; 85%) of the
crew were included in the study, although all 296 available members
consented to surveillance questionnaire and cultures (296/313; 94.6%).
Seventy-three (73/266; 27.4%) were colonized with S. aureus, 18
of which were MRSA (18/73; 24% and 18/266; 6.8%). Pulsed-field gel
electrophoresis (PFGE) revealed all strains were pulsed-field type (PFT)
USA 300. Key factors within the past 12 months included antibiotic
use (OR=2.88, p=0.036), medical care (OR=3.32, p=0.011), or history of
skin problems (OR=2.73, p=0.032).
Conclusions: Surveillance indicated a surprising rate
of CA-MRSA carriage among sailors assigned to this ship, which was
likely associated with the SSTI infections among crew members while
previously at sea. Important risk factors in this confined population
included recent access to outpatient healthcare services. The PFGE types
were USA 300, which is commonly community-associated, and not a
healthcare-associated strain by definition.
Implications: In addition to its established public
health importance in SSTI within civilian communities, this report
demonstrates the increasing role of CA-MRSA as an emerging pathogen
among military populations. Hawaii’s large military population and
strategic location underscores the potential impact of drug-resistant
staphylococcus infections on military readiness in the Pacific.
More
Brief
Introduction to Health Disparities By Gender and Marital Status
Kathleen Kromer Baker1,
Alvin T. Onaka1, Brian Horiuchi1, James
Dannemiller2.
1Office
of Health Status Monitoring, Hawai‘i State Department. of Health.
2SMS
Research, Honolulu, Hawai‘i.
The Hawai‘i Health Survey (HHS) provides useful information to document
health disparities. Prior published information from the HHS
indicated health disparities by ethnicity, income, geographic area, and
insurance. However, gender and marital status are less well
documented. Introductory information provided below illustrates
that gender and marital status can also be important factors in the
health of adults of Hawaii.
More
Improving Cultural
Compentency: Smart Strategies for Working with Filipinos
Jeny
Bissell1
1Maui
District Health Office, Hawai‘i State Department of Health.
Issue:
The issues and
concerns in the Filipino community are best illustrated in the following
“WE BELIEVE STATEMENTS” by the Maui Filipino Working who is Jeny
Bissell, Virginia Cantorna, Kim Compoc and Cornelia Soberano.
One of the primary
concerns is that Filipinos are not accessing services and that there is
a provisional need for culturally appropriate services in the Filipino
community.
More
Mutual Aid Agreements Between Public and Private- Sector Laboratories
Christopher Lum Lee1
1Hawaii
State Judiciary
Objective
The
purpose of this discussion is to explain the importance of mutual aid
agreements between public and private-sector laboratories in public
health incident preparedness and response. This discussion also
incorporates the elements of an effective mutual aid agreement, how a
mutual aid agreement is to become implemented, and at which point it can
be concluded that mutual aid agreements are a best practice today.
more
Malama I Na Keiki,
Ending Non-therapeutic Infant Circumcision Through Education
Joseph Kassel, N.D., L.Ac1., Misha Kassel, MD2,
Clare Loprinzi, Traditional Midwife, CPM3 1
Private practice, Holualoa, Hawai‘i, 2
Stanford University School of Medicine,
3Mālama
I Nā Keiki, Captain Cook, Hawai‘i
The object of our discussion is not that your words will gain victory
over mine, or that mine will triumph over yours, but that together, we
may discover the perfect truth.” (Socrates)
Abstract
Medical non-therapeutic infant circumcision began in the nineteen
century to prevent masturbation, which was believed to cause disease, by
excising the most sensitive part of the genitals, as well as inflicting
psychological and physical pain to discourage the practice. Subsequently
there have been a number of rationales provided for this procedure,
including prevention of sexually transmitted infections, urinary tract
infections and, most recently, HIV transmission. These rationales for
the procedure have either limited support from flawed research or often
contradictory evidence. The surgical removal of healthy tissue from a
nonconsenting infant raises ethical and human rights concerns. The
foreskin is of importance to male genital health and function throughout
the lifespan. The loss of these functions, the pain and potential
complications of the procedure, in addition to the above concerns, make
it necessary for us to revaluate and discontinue this procedure.
More
The Protective Effect of
Circumcision in the Transmission of HIV: A New Perspective on an Old
Procedure
Nicole Valcour, Dominic Chow, The Clint Spencer Clinic, John A Burns
School of Medicine, University of
Hawai‘i at Manoa
In this paper, we set out to
address the topic e of adult male circumcision as it is used in the
prevention of HIV transmission. As with most issues related to
circumcision, arguments on both sides of the debate can be quite
compelling. We hope to infuse the discussion with some of the relevant
published data on circumcision in southern Africa. In this way, we hope
to raise the level of understanding of the subject generally, and
in the process new ideas and concerns might be brought to light on this
new application of an historically dynamic and controversial procedure.
. Since early in the epidemic of HIV/AIDS, large discrepancies in HIV
prevalence within and between countries on the continent of Africa have
been noted, and these disparities cannot be readily explained by
differences in sexual behavior patterns or the differential presence of
STI’s. Neither can the age of the epidemic in the country, nor
differences in circulating strains of the virus explain this variation.1
There is an area of the African continent that has been widely described
as the “AIDS Belt”, meaning that the highest prevalence of HIV infection
can be found in this area. What has been demonstrated in many cases is
that this area of the continent is comprised of societies that do not
practice male circumcision.
More
We offer our humble apology to A.C. Whelen for the incorrect name
spelling. Corrections have been made to the HTML version but PDF
changes are unavailable.